“ Came for a slice of pizza, and that is what I got. It was great! Service is a bit lacking, we stood around for a while, and then sat for a while, however the waters came quick. Place looks great inside, seemed clean and well taken care of. We like coming here after wrestling matches at the Oriental, I suggest you try both of those things! ”

“ We were in a hurry and Nikki made sure we had everything we needed and was super friendly. The pizza was awesome, as always. ”

“ Went to a whiskey tour at Stranahan's. After that, we decide to sit out on the patio and have a couple of whiskeys while listening to music We were hungry so we ordered Fat Sullys. It was delivered on time and honestly one of the best pizzas I have had I'm originally from New York so I have an idea of a good pizza There was just as good as anything I've had and gigantic slices Garlic knots are also excellent. ”

“ This establishment is also home to the Denver Biscuit Co that you may be looking for... go up to the door & you'll see it posted. So, whether you're looking for biscuits, pizza or burgers, you're covered. Both sammies were great. The cinnamon roll we wouldn't order again... despite all that frosting, it was pretty hard to cut through the edges. Service was great & loved the outdoor seating ”

“ Fat Sully's takes me back to college, grabbing that late night slice after bar hopping. I've had Sully's both in-house slices/drinks and take-out full pies and they continue to have my favorite pep slice in all of Denver. The dough has great flavor and I think it's the cheese that really makes it. With a pie that large you worry about quality and consistency, but it's been great every time. I also love their burger and Sully's fries. The chipotle ranch is damn good and I want a whole bottle of that stuff. Only knock is it gets busy AF so pick-up can be a long process at times. It's cool they have a separate take-out slice window. Love that they're available for delivery. ”

“ Continues to be our absolute favorite pizza! And the best people! We really enjoy the dragon fruit drink too ! I like that there are ciders here too. Crystal and I always get that huge pizza and then we have leftovers for days. We have come sometimes during trivia. We love coming late night as well it's nice to have a place open late and enjoy it! I can't say enough about the people here too. Definitely try the garlic knots they are pretty epic ! ”

“ Another great visit last night! I wanted to give a shout out to Nikki who was an absolute delight! We got the loaded garlic knots and our usual gigantic pepperoni pizza so we have lots of leftovers to take home. Ryan got the dragon lady drink and really enjoyed it so much he got 2! This place continues to be consistent and the best bang for the buck and delicious food quality pizza! Also everyone working here tonight was tons of smiles and seemed to be enjoying the night and the atmosphere was so fun and happy vibes. Ryan had just got done a long week away on a work trip so we did a late night visit and it was such a nice way to start off ryan's weekend back home! Thank you Fat Sully's! There's other photos still on it from way earlier and even years ago but the new pics are the 3 videos on the end the drink the pizza and the knots videos ! ”

“ This is a rock solid New York style pizza. It has all the right ingredients. They also travel well. Personally, this is hands down the best NY style in town at the moment. Challenge me. ”

“ This is the only place for late night eats on Tennyson and it hits the spot! They have tons of fantastic beers on tap and a full bar. There is something for everyone. The pizza is New York Style and you add whatever toppings you want to your slice. They have the classics and some unique options for toppings. Pepperoni, Garlic & Banana Peppers is one of my favs. They have specials for a late night slice and a beer. We have always been able to find a table or two in the evening after a show at The Oriental. And, folks sitting nearby have been really friendly and joined our conversations on occasion. ”

“ This was my first experience with Fat Sully's on Tennyson. I was picking up pizza and knots for the fam. I called in my order and was given a 20-30 minute completion time. Reasonable considering it was prime dinner time. The parking lot has two "To Go" parking spots for folks picking up. I appreciate that as parking in that neighborhood can be challenging. I showed up about 25 minutes after my call in and my order was ready. In addition to the parking spots, there is a to-go window. Instead of going into the restaurant to wait for carryout, there is a seating area outside. I got my order and headed home. We had a red sauced pizza with Italian sausage, oven roasted green peppers and oven roasted onions. A little note on the fact that they have oven roasted veg for the 'za, this is fabu! Sometimes raw, can still be a little harsh even after a run through a pizza oven. The oven roasted veg has a bit more sweetness and went perfectly with the sausage. When preparing to order (i.e. polling the kids on what sauce, toppings, etc.) I asked, "Do we want to get the loaded garlic knots?" To which the reply was, "Mom, that's a rhetorical question, right?" We got the loaded garlic knots. So advice for other folks...Get the loaded garlic knots!! They were delicious! The regular knots have garlic and parmesan. Loaded comes with a drizzle of pesto and two dipping sauces, creamy mozzarella with more pesto and their red sauce. Mmmmm. Full tummies and happy family. ”